topleft
L'chaim...or not
Posted: Tuesday February 13, 2007 at 10:04 pm
Keywords: Stephen Morse
Professor Steve Phipps pours champagne at the wine tasting preceptorial in 2004. (Geoff Robinson/DP)

Each semester since I arrived at Penn, I have tried to take a preceptorial. But I've still never been to a preceptorial.

I've come to learn that the preceptorial system is ludicrous. Here's why:

  • Many preceptorials are cancelled.
  • There have been semesters when I've never found out at all if I was accepted or rejected.
  • This semester, my final semester at Penn, I am particularly irate. Many of my close friends and I signed up for the wine tasting preceptorial. And boy was I excited when I registered on Penn in Touch and the course appeared on my schedule.

    But yesterday, I received and email from the preceptorial committee informing that I was on the waitlist for the course.

    Yup, I was PO'd when I got this. My housemates were also waitlisted.

    College senior Mandeep Kalra, head of the preceptorial committee told me in an email interview that that there were 20 spots available in this preceptorial for the 900 people who signed up. This means that there are 880 people on the waitlist. That translates into 880 pissed off seniors, about 1/3 of the class!

    But budget constraints don't necessarily limit the number of students able to enroll in preceptorials. According to Mandeep, the budget for this year was $20,000 and will hopefully increase in the future.

    What irritates me even more than the fact that I didn't get into the class is that Penn In Touch didn't tell me that the class was full. All semester I planned to spend my Wednesdays in March sipping wine (during spring break for starters, and continuing upon return to Penn. Registration for preceptorials should operate like regular registration — you should find out immediately whether the class is full or not.

    Maybe we shouldn't all be bitter- there's still room in the knitting preceptorial for any interested parties.

    Can you please write about something with significance. I swear to god if the next article is about your roommate leaving the toilet seat up I am going to find you and kick you in the groin. It is a FREE CLASS ON WINE TASTING if you want to go to college for wine tasting go to a culinary school.
    - Jared
    I am a freshman, and this fall I enrolled in and attended all three of the preceptorials I wanted. None were canceled, and all were extremely interesting. Sorry about your luck.
    - Kathryn
    Dear Stephen, I sincerely believe that you are being impartial on your claims against Preceptorials. First, if you signed for Preceptorials during all semesters since you got to Penn and did not get it, I am sorry to tell you, but it is a matter of lack of luck. Second, how can you claim that it is Preceptorials' choice to increase the number of students attending the wine tasting when there isn't enough money to do so? Of course, there is U$20,000, however, please don't forget that this money is to meet the ENTIRE student body demand for ONE YEAR. In other words, the money has to last for about 70 Preceptorials. Or perhaps you believe that the entire budget should be spent on your interests. Who knows... Hope you drive your efforts next time towards asking for a great budget to this group -- maybe this way a vast number of seniors can enjoy wine tasting.
    - Thomaz
    Professors ask for no more than about 20 students in a preceptorial...can you imagine a wine preceptorial with 100 people? That would be chaotic. Oh and by the way...there are FIVE knitting preceptorials since it is so popular. Some time slots are more advantageous than others and that is why some sections were underenrolled while others were overenrolled. Good job not reporting all the relevant facts.
    - Katie
    I agree with what everyone else has said here. Also, I would like to add that it says explicitly on the website and in any e-mail notifications sent out about signing up for preceptorials that having it appear on Penn InTouch does NOT mean that you are registered for the class. So please, stop acting so damn entitled.
    - Julia
    You're a douchebag, not even one of those cool douchebags with the flipped collars, but one of those who sucks members but doesn't have the balls to admit it.
    - Ryan
    If you're so excited about sipping wine, why don't you just hook up with a hobo?
    - Kelly
    You are truly a moron.
    - Someone Who Knows
    Comment:
    Your Name:
    Verify:
    Note: If any field is left blank, it will not be posted.
    Stephen Morse
    drawer
    >>About this blog
    The Spin is an opinion blog with an eye toward criticizing, mocking and analyzing the goings on at Penn, Philly and the wider — if less important — world.

    Editor: David Lei | E-mail

    Other DP blogs:  

    >>Recent posts

    Authors
    All CategoriesGuest Blogs
    Last Post: Oct. 22
    Mike Tate
    Last Post: Oct. 20
    Nick McAvoy
    Last Post: Oct. 19
    Lindsey Stull
    Last Post: Oct. 19
    Caroline Pearsall
    Last Post: Oct. 19
    Nick Barr
    Last Post: Oct. 18
    Simeon McMillan
    Last Post: Oct. 18
    Collin Beck
    Last Post: Oct. 18
    Morgan Hennessy
    Last Post: Oct. 15
    Dan Brickley
    Last Post: Oct. 10
    Elizabeth Song
    Last Post: Oct. 5
    Lindsey Stull
    Last Post: Sep. 6
    Ali Jackson
    Last Post: Sep. 4
    Spring 2007
    Last Post: Apr. 25
    Julie Siegel
    Last Post: Apr. 25
    James Russell
    Last Post: Apr. 20
    Evan Goldin
    Last Post: Apr. 20
    Ruben Brosbe
    Last Post: Apr. 20
    Sarah Min
    Last Post: Apr. 19
    John Kneeland
    Last Post: Apr. 19
    Camille Hardiman
    Last Post: Apr. 19
    Julie Steinberg
    Last Post: Apr. 18
    Sharon Udasin
    Last Post: Apr. 18
    Josh Stanfield
    Last Post: Mar. 2
    Stephen Morse
    Last Post: Feb. 17
    Fall 2006
    Last Post: Jan. 12

    >>Recent Comments
    Making Penn courses more rewarding
    "Damn, that never happened when I was Penn. I really would have loved to bond with my seminar classes more, esp writing classes. Nice piece. …" — Caren Lissner '93

    BlackBerry hating
    " way to trivialize the words of such an inspirational man into a statement about something so irrelevant to his message. i understand what you were trying to do…" — hbap

    Point: The UA has a responsibility to represent students and address their concerns
    "Thank web master.…" — MAzhar shah

    I scratch your back; you scratch mine
    "i think they realize the true meaning of friendship Wholesale Blank t-shirts…" — Jessica




    >>Search the blogs