![]() |
| (Alexandra Bell/The Crimson) President Gutmann visits Harvard earlier this semester. |
Penn President Amy Gutmann has made Harvard’s official list of 30 “contenders” for its presidential opening, according to a late-breaking story in The Harvard Crimson. The list also includes Columbia President Lee Bollinger and Princeton President Shirley Tilghman.
The Crimson has only learned 11 of the 30 names on the list, after “two sources close to the Harvard Corporation” leaked the information. The list was formed by Harvard’s presidential search committee and presented on Sunday to the school’s Board of Overseers, an influential group of alumni.
So, what does this all mean?
For one, it means Harvard didn’t rule Gutmann out after her Halloween photo fiasco. It also means that Harvard doesn’t care whether its candidates have expressed interest in the position, as Gutmann publicly has not (despite being named a finalist for the position when it was last vacant in 2001).
But most important, for Penn, Gutmann’s inclusion on the list means she must now look to Rutgers and pull a Greg Schiano.
Schiano, of course, is the Scarlet Knights’ football coach and the man who last year led them to their first bowl game in 27 years. The man who transformed a team that lost a game 80-7 in 2001 into a 16th-ranked contender in 2006. The man who was just named coach of the year.
Of course, coaches of the year tend to elicit interest from powerful schools on the prowl. And so it was with Schiano last week, when the University of Miami (Fl.) came a-knocking, hoping to hire Schiano as its replacement for the fired Larry Coker.
At the time, Schiano had two main choices and one secondary choice: First, he had to choose whether he wanted to stay at Rutgers, where he is under contract until 2012; second, he had to decide how to handle his decision–i.e. whether to go public about his decision to stay or leave.
As it turns out, Schiano has decided to stay at Rutgers. But That’s not why his actions should serve as the perfect example for Gutmann. No, what sets Schiano apart is the way he quickly quashed rumors of his move to Miami by publicly asking the school to remove his name from its list of candidates before the end of the season.
With a bowl game still on the schedule, Rutgers players can now focus on football instead of their coach’s possible departure. Which makes all difference in the world, because no athlete appreciates playing for someone who’s off to “bigger and better places.”
Or to quote Philadelphia Inquirer columnist Jim Salisbury, no one wants to play in the “Stepping-Stone Bowl.”
If Gutmann doesn’t yet know whether she wants to remain at Penn, she must decide now. That should be the first move. And if she decides to stay here, she must immediately and publicly petition Harvard to remove her name from its candidate roster.
Her credibility as a fundraiser for Penn’s long-term projects (like eastward expansion and financial aid growth) will suffer if she remains silent, even though she hasn’t actively expressed interest in leaving.
For alumni won’t trust she who views Penn as the Stepping-Stone School.






